Edinburgh and Glasgow are forty-seven miles apart, connected by trains that run every fifteen minutes, and they have almost nothing in common as music cities. Understanding the difference is essential to understanding the Scottish live music economy, and the standard tourism narrative (Glasgow gritty, Edinburgh cultured) does not remotely capture what is actually different about them.
The scale asymmetry
Glasgow has more than twice the population of Edinburgh (roughly 630,000 to 510,000, though the wider metro figures narrow the gap). More importantly for a music economy, Glasgow has a larger working-class population, a stronger tradition of pub and small-club culture, and a set of venues that between them programme more shows per week than Edinburgh does. Edinburgh has a larger tourist population by an order of magnitude, particularly in August during the festivals, but the tourism does not translate into year-round venue demand in the same way.
The venue-density difference
Glasgow has Barrowland (1,900 cap), OVO Hydro (12,000 cap), SEC Armadillo (3,000 cap), Old Fruitmarket (1,000 cap), SWG3 Warehouse (1,250 cap), SWG3 Galvanizers (2,500 cap), Sub Club (400 cap), King Tut’s (300 cap), Stereo, Broadcast, Nice N Sleazy, Mono, Hug and Pint, 13th Note, La Cheetah, Berkeley Suite, plus various pub-scale rooms. That is a genuinely full stack of venue capacities. Edinburgh has the Corn Exchange (2,500 cap), Usher Hall (2,900 cap, seated classical), Queen’s Hall (900 cap seated), Assembly Rooms, La Belle Angele (300 cap), Sneaky Pete’s (100 cap), Bongo Club (300 cap), Voodoo Rooms (200 cap), Mash House, Wee Red Bar, Cabaret Voltaire (closed as a music venue). The mid-cap segment in Edinburgh (roughly 400 to 2,000 cap) is genuinely underserved and this is the single most significant infrastructural difference between the two cities.
What Edinburgh does have
Edinburgh has Sneaky Pete’s on the Cowgate, which is one of the best small clubs in the UK for its size. It has been running since 2007 and its 100-capacity room programmes serious touring electronic and left-field acts. Bongo Club and Cabaret Voltaire have historically covered the mid-size club programming; Cabaret Voltaire’s transition away from being a music venue (it now operates as a hospitality venue) was one of the more consequential Edinburgh losses. La Belle Angele covers 300-cap live shows in the Cowgate. Assembly Rooms and Queen’s Hall handle acoustic and classical touring stops. Usher Hall covers the seated adult-orientated pop and classical calendar. St Cecilia’s Hall does chamber music.
Edinburgh’s Festival month and its distortion effect
Edinburgh in August is a different city. The Fringe (roughly 3,500 shows across a month, mostly theatre and comedy but including a genuine slice of music programming) and the Edinburgh International Festival (a smaller, higher-end classical, opera and dance festival) together attract about 4.4 million tickets sold across the month. The Edinburgh International Book Festival, the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo and various other festivals overlap. For music, this matters because a significant number of touring artists play Edinburgh only in August (often as one-off Fringe shows) and skip the city the rest of the year. This distorts the touring calendar in ways that make the year-round Edinburgh scene look thinner than it actually is, but also masks the genuine underlying infrastructural gap.
Glasgow’s festival calendar
Glasgow’s festival calendar is smaller and more musically focused: TRNSMT (three days of headline acts at Glasgow Green in July), Celtic Connections (a major folk and world music festival in January, run out of the Old Fruitmarket, Royal Concert Hall and City Halls), and various smaller events. TRNSMT has effectively replaced T in the Park (which ran at Balado and then Strathallan until 2016) as the major Scottish festival, though it is a city-centre one-day-repeated event rather than a full weekender.
The scene differences
Glasgow has a working underground club scene of international significance (Sub Club, La Cheetah, Berkeley Suite, SWG3’s electronic programming) that Edinburgh cannot match. Glasgow has a working guitar-band and indie scene (Chemikal Underground orbit, the Belle and Sebastian continuing infrastructure, the current wave of Scottish indie) that runs through the small-venue circuit. Edinburgh has a serious classical infrastructure (Scottish Chamber Orchestra, the Edinburgh International Festival programming, Queen’s Hall and Usher Hall) that Glasgow’s is stronger than the outside perception but where Edinburgh has genuine international-level programming during the festivals.
Practical differences for musicians
Working artists based in Scotland almost universally play Glasgow more often than Edinburgh, and often as their default Scottish date. The Glasgow crowd’s reputation for enthusiasm is not a myth: Barrowlands and Sub Club audiences are demonstrably more energetic than most UK crowds. The practical reason Glasgow gets more shows is that promoters know they can sell more tickets there. This is a network effect: because Glasgow has more shows, it has more audiences, which brings more shows.
Practical differences for audiences
For a music tourist choosing between the two cities, the answer is Glasgow unless you are visiting during Edinburgh’s August festival month, in which case Edinburgh is unique. Glasgow has more genuinely underground clubs. It has a stronger small-to-mid-cap venue map. It has better pub-scale live music. The Edinburgh classical calendar outside August is smaller than Glasgow’s, though the Usher Hall and Queen’s Hall programmes are of high quality.
What has closed in each city
Edinburgh losses: Cabaret Voltaire (as a music venue), Studio 24 (closed 2017), Henry’s Cellar Bar (long gone), various pubs with small stages. The Liquid Room burnt out in 2007 and reopened. Studio 24’s closure was one of the significant recent losses. Glasgow losses covered in the Glasgow guide: the Arches, the Art School, the Glue Factory. Both cities have lost venues but Glasgow’s remaining infrastructure has held up better because it started from a larger base.
The classical dimension
Edinburgh has the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, an internationally-important small orchestra, and it hosts the Edinburgh International Festival’s classical programming. Glasgow has the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, the Royal Scottish National Orchestra (also plays Edinburgh), the Scottish Opera and the Scottish Ballet. The Royal Conservatoire of Scotland is in Glasgow. The classical strength is roughly matched but distributed differently: Edinburgh’s chamber music economy is stronger, Glasgow’s orchestral and operatic infrastructure is larger.
Getting between the two
ScotRail trains from Glasgow Queen Street to Edinburgh Waverley run every fifteen minutes during the day and take about fifty minutes. The two cities function almost as a single music market for people willing to make the trip. It is genuinely feasible to see a show in one city and travel home to the other on the same evening, though the last trains around 23:00-23:30 impose a curfew. Many working musicians and industry people commute between the two cities routinely.
Which city, if you had to pick one
For year-round music, Glasgow. For August, Edinburgh. For classical, both, depending on what you are looking for. For underground clubs, Glasgow with a wide margin. For pub and small-venue live, Glasgow. For seated adult-orientated pop and acoustic tours, Edinburgh is often the better booking. For a music tourist visiting Scotland once, do the two-city trip; the trains are frequent enough that you can fit both in a weekend and cover more ground than trying to stay in one city.
Add Music.co.uk as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
